With the Super Bowl being tomorrow (Go Eagles!), I thought I'd do another post about it. Specifically, trying to figure out who was the worst quarterback to win a Super Bowl, and also what was the worst individual performance for a winning quarterback. (For starters, clearly--I'm not counting backup quarterbacks for worst individual performance, since most play like a series at most. With one exception which I'll discuss in a bit.) So, I looked at the quarterbacks and the results for all 58 Super Bowls, and tried to crunch the numbers. Obviously, the answers to these questions are admittedly a little subjective, depending on what statistics you value the most. I decided to use quarterback rating and Approximate Value (AV) for these determinations, which I got from the pro-football-reference.com website. (If you're really curious, in their glossary they have detailed explanations on how they calculate both of these stats.) Anyway, let's get to it. I'll explore each as a bottom 10 list, going least bad to most bad. Plus, as usual, I'm not going to type out the Roman numerals for each Super Bowl, I'll convert them to our regular numbers.
Worst Quarterback Rating for a Super Bowl Winning Quarterback:
10) 79.9 Brad Johnson, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Super Bowl 37. Johnson completed 18 of 34 passes (52.9%) for 215 yards, 2 touchdowns, and 1 interception.
9) 78.1 Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs, Super Bowl 54. Mahomes completed 26 of 42 passes (61.9%) for 286 yards, 2 touchdowns, and 2 interceptions.
8) 77.2 Troy Aikman, Dallas Cowboys, Super Bowl 28. Aikman completed 19 of 27 passes (70.4%) for 207 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception.
7) 75.1 Joe Theismann, Washington Redskins, Super Bowl 17. Theismann completed 15 of 23 passes (65.2%) for 143 yards, 2 touchdowns, and 2 interceptions.
6) 71.4 Tom Brady, New England Patriots, Super Bowl 53. Brady completed 21 of 35 passes (60%) for 262 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception.
5) 68.1 John Unitas, Baltimore Colts, Super Bowl 5. Unitas completed 3 of 9 passes (33.3%) for 88 yards, 1 touchdown, and 2 interceptions. He also lost a fumble. (a)
4) 56.6 Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos, Super Bowl 50. Manning completed 13 of 23 passes (56.5%) for 141 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception. He also fumbled twice, losing 1.
3) 54.0 Earl Morrall, Baltimore Colts, Super Bowl 5. Morrall completed 7 of 15 passes (46.7%) for 147 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception. (a)
2) 51.9 John Elway, Denver Broncos, Super Bowl 32. Elway completed 12 of 22 passes (54.5%) for 123 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception. He did rush for a touchdown, though.
1) 22.6 Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers, Super Bowl 40. Ben completed 9 of 21 passes (42.9%) for 123 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 2 interceptions. He did rush for a touchdown, on the plus side. (b)
(a) I'm including both Unitas and Morrall for Super Bowl 5, since Unitas started and played roughly half the game before being injured. Morrall came in to replace him down 13-6 and the Colts eventually won 16-13. Although, as the stats indicate, neither quarterback played well at all, and the Colts arguably won despite their quarterbacks.
(b) To give some further indication of how bad Roethlisberger played, if he'd simply spiked the ball into the ground on every passing attempt his rating would have increased to 39.6!
Worst Lifetime Quarterbacks to Win a Super Bowl, as Determined by AV:
11) 108 Jim Plunkett. Jim played in 15 seasons, from 1971-77 and 1979-86, for the New England Patriots, San Francisco 49ers, and Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders. He started 144 of 157 games, with a won-loss record of 72-72. He completed 52.5% of his passes for 25,882 yards, 164 touchdowns, and 198 interceptions. His lifetime rating was 67.5, and he was never named to the Pro Bowl or All-Pro teams. Rushing-wise he accumulated 1337 yards, on a 4.1 average, for 14 touchdowns. (a)
10) 107 Joe Theismann. Joe played 12 seasons, from 1974-85, all with the then Washington Redskins. He started 124 of 167 games, with a 77-47 won-loss record. He completed 56.7% of his passes for 25,206 yards, 160 touchdowns, and 138 interceptions. His lifetime rating was 77.4, and he was named to 2 Pro Bowls and 1 All-Pro team. He also rushed for 1885 yards (5.1 average) and 17 touchdowns.
9) 93 Brad Johnson. Johnson played 15 years, from 1994-2008, with the Minnesota Vikings, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and others. He started 125 of 177 total games, with a 72-53 won-loss record. He completed 61.7% of his passes for 29,054 yards, 166 touchdowns, 122 interceptions, and a rating of 82.5. He was a Pro Bowler 2 times. He also rushed for 657 yards (2.4 average) and 8 touchdowns. (b)
8) 86+ Earl Morrall. (AV is only calculated for 1960 and beyond, and Morrall played a few seasons before this. So he would have had more AV, but I don't know how much. Presumably not enough to make it off this list, but arguably better than Johnson's at least.) Anyway, Morrall played 21 seasons, from 1956-76, with the Detroit Lions, Baltimore Colts, Miami Dolphins, and others. He started 102 of 255 games, with a won-loss record of 63-36. He completed 51.3% of his passes for 20,809 yards, 161 touchdowns, 148 interceptions, and a rating of 74.1. He was named to 2 Pro Bowls and 2 All-Pro teams. He rushed for 878 yards (3.7 average) and 8 touchdowns. (c)
7) 75 Jalen Hurts. Hurts is still active, but so far has played 5 seasons, from 2020-2024, all with the Philadelphia Eagles. He's started 66 of 77 total games, with a 46-20 won-loss record. He has completed 64.4% of his passes for 14,667 yards, 85 touchdowns, 39 interceptions, and a rating of 93.5. He's been named to 2 Pro Bowls. He's also rushed for 3,13 yards (4.6 average), and 55 touchdowns.
6) 71 Jim McMahon. Jim played in 15 seasons, from 1982-96, with the Chicago Bears, Philadelphia Eagles, Green Bay Packers, and others. He started 97 of 119 games, with a won-loss record of 67-30. He completed 58% of his passes for 18,148 yards, 100 touchdowns, 90 interceptions, and a rating of 78.2. He was named to 1 Pro Bowl. He rushed for 1631 yards (4.8 average) and 16 touchdowns.
5) 65 Jeff Hostetler. Jeff played in 12 seasons, from 1985-86, and 1988-97, with the New York Giants, Raiders, and Washington Redskins. He started 83 of 152 games, with a won-loss record of 51-32. He completed 58% of his passes for 16,430 yards, 94 touchdowns, 71 interceptions, and an 80.5 rating. He was named to 1 Pro Bowl. He rushed for 1391 yards (4.4 average) and 17 touchdowns.
4) 63 Doug Williams. Williams played in 9 seasons, from 1978-82, and 1986-89. (He sat out the 1983 season due to a contract dispute, and then played in the USFL from 1984-85.) Doug played for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Washington Redskins. He started 81 of 88 games, with a won-loss record of 38-42-1. He completed 49.5% of his passes for 16,998 yards, 100 touchdowns, 93 interceptions, and a rating of 69.4. He was not named to any Pro Bowls or All-Pro teams. He rushed for 884 yards (4.0 average) and 15 touchdowns.
3) 60 Mark Rypien. Rypien played in 11 seasons, from 1988-97, and 2001, with the Washington Redskins, Cleveland Browns, Philadelphia Eagles, and others. He started 78 of 104 games, and had a won-loss record of 47-31. He completed 56.1% of his passes for 18,473 yards, 115 touchdowns, 88 interceptions, and a rating of 78.9. He was named to 2 Pro Bowls. He also rushed for 166 yards (1.3 average) and 8 touchdowns.
2) 60 Trent Dilfer. (I ranked Dilfer as worse than Rypien despite their identical AVs, since Rypien had a better rating, touchdown/interception ratio, and more Pro Bowls.) Dilfer played 13 seasons, with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Baltimore Ravens, Seattle Seahawks, and others. He started 113 of 130 games, with a won-loss record of 58-55. He completed 55.5% of his passes for 20,518 yards, 113 touchdowns, 129 interceptions, and a 70.2 rating. He was named to 1 Pro Bowl. He rushed for 853 yards (3.4 average), and 5 touchdowns.
1) 37 Nick Foles. Foles played in 11 seasons, from 2012-22, with the Philadelphia Eagles, Kansas City Chiefs, Chicago Bears, and others. He started 58 of 71 games, with a won-loss record of 29-29. He completed 62.4% of his passes for 14,227 yards, 82 touchdowns, 47 interceptions, and a rating of 86.2. He also rushed for 407 yards (2.7 average) and 6 touchdowns.
(a) Plunkett, of course, won 2 Super Bowls, 15 and 18, both with the Raiders. I think pretty much everyone would agree that he's the worst to win 2.
(b) Johnson also was the first(?) to throw a touchdown pass to himself. (He threw a pass that was batted back by a defender to him, and he caught it and ran it in for a touchdown.) I know a couple of others, including Marcus Mariota and Josh Allen have done it since.
(c) Morrall also was part of the winning Super Bowl Miami Dolphin teams for Super Bowls 7 and 8, but as a backup. He actually started much of the 1972 regular season and even the first two playoff games, but Bob Griese was able to start Super Bowl 7.
So there you have it. And yes, As an Eagles fan it does gall me a bit to have to acknowledge that by some metrics Nick Foles was the worst quarterback to win a Super Bowl. And if you're curious, Jalen Hurts's current lifetime AV is 75, meaning he would qualify for the latter list if he wins tomorrow. But of course, he should play many more years and raise it up, I would hope. But this is all speculation at this point. (Update: Hurts did win, so I put him on the list. Which explains why this one now has 11 quarterbacks. I'll try to continue to update this every year, until Hurts hopefully leaves it.)